In a comment to June 19’s post, Anonymous asked what I mean by “pure” annuity. “Pure annuity” is not a term of art, I’m afraid. I made it up. Forgive me for not defining my terms.
What I meant by “pure” annuity is an annuity that pays an agreed annual payment, beginning at an agreed starting date, either for your life, or for the life of you and your spouse. It is “pure” in the sense that it does not contain the following features:
• Payment does not vary with the performance of some asset class, such as with the S&P 500 index; that’s called a “variable” annuity. In my mind, however, an annuity that varies with an inflation index is an acceptably pure annuity.
• Payment is not guaranteed for a minimum period, such as 10 years, should you not live that long. It’s purely for your life. In my mind, however, an annuity that continues for the life of your spouse, should he survive you, is pure enough. Most couples properly view themselves as a single economic unit.
I’m no expert on annuities. I know what I like about them in concept, but I don’t know enough about them to know when they’re a good deal or a rip-off. For a good informative website about annuities, go to AnnuityDigest.com.
Showing posts with label Savings Buckets. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Savings Buckets. Show all posts
Monday, June 29, 2009
Wednesday, June 24, 2009
More on Short-Term Tax Savings vs. Long-term Benefit
Editorial note: This post was supposed to appear on June 23.
Yesterday’s post discussed how there is often a trade-off between short-term tax savings and long-term tax benefit. Paul Anonymous identified one particular manifestation of that issue as he considers whether to contribute to a non-deductible IRA now, or wait until just before he converts it to a Roth IRA in early 2010. The former approach likely has a slightly higher short-term tax cost. The latter approach likely has a slightly higher long-term tax benefit. How do you know which outweighs the other?
Before providing some rules of thumb (which, as we all know, are always wrong), a couple of observations.
Observation #1: You can never know for sure. Accept that, as in all things in life, you must make a decision in the face of uncertainty about what the future will bring. All you can do is make your best guess.
Observation #2: (This one is hard for many people to swallow.) Your guess must necessarily be based on long-term projections. That’s because long-term benefits can only be assessed in the long term. Duh.
Observation #3: Be sure you’re comparing the right output. It’s not which approach pays the least in taxes. Rather, for most of us, it’s which approach leads you to the highest after-tax retirement spending. (For a lucky few—the wealthy—the right output to measure is which approach leads to your children’s highest after-tax wealth.)
So how do you know if you benefit more from a lower short-term tax or from the long-term benefit of a larger Roth IRA? Here’s a couple of rules of thumb:
Rule #1: If you’re 20 or more years away from retirement, then you’ve got enough time to benefit from long-term savings. Pay the higher tax.
Rule #2: If you’re wealthy, regardless of age, then you’ve got enough time to benefit from long-term savings. By “wealthy” I mean either of the following: (1) you have enough assets outside your tax-favored retirement plans to meet your spending needs during your lifetime, and don’t ever need to tap into your tax-favored retirement accounts, except as required by law; or (2) you are spending as much as you care to during your lifetime, and any additional resources will end up in the hands of your beneficiaries after your death. While both categories of "wealthy" benefit from long-term savings, the latter category (the "really wealthy" (?)), derive a greater degree of benefit than the former.
Unfortunately, those two rules of thumb don’t nearly cover the whole waterfront. They still fail to address Paul Anonymous’ situation and that of most readers of this blog. Most of us are not wealthy, and are either at or too near retirement to make use of Rule #1. In that case, the only approach I can recommend is to do a full-blown long-term financial projection. Or, short of that, do what Paul Anonymous is doing and go with your gut instinct.
Yesterday’s post discussed how there is often a trade-off between short-term tax savings and long-term tax benefit. Paul Anonymous identified one particular manifestation of that issue as he considers whether to contribute to a non-deductible IRA now, or wait until just before he converts it to a Roth IRA in early 2010. The former approach likely has a slightly higher short-term tax cost. The latter approach likely has a slightly higher long-term tax benefit. How do you know which outweighs the other?
Before providing some rules of thumb (which, as we all know, are always wrong), a couple of observations.
Observation #1: You can never know for sure. Accept that, as in all things in life, you must make a decision in the face of uncertainty about what the future will bring. All you can do is make your best guess.
Observation #2: (This one is hard for many people to swallow.) Your guess must necessarily be based on long-term projections. That’s because long-term benefits can only be assessed in the long term. Duh.
Observation #3: Be sure you’re comparing the right output. It’s not which approach pays the least in taxes. Rather, for most of us, it’s which approach leads you to the highest after-tax retirement spending. (For a lucky few—the wealthy—the right output to measure is which approach leads to your children’s highest after-tax wealth.)
So how do you know if you benefit more from a lower short-term tax or from the long-term benefit of a larger Roth IRA? Here’s a couple of rules of thumb:
Rule #1: If you’re 20 or more years away from retirement, then you’ve got enough time to benefit from long-term savings. Pay the higher tax.
Rule #2: If you’re wealthy, regardless of age, then you’ve got enough time to benefit from long-term savings. By “wealthy” I mean either of the following: (1) you have enough assets outside your tax-favored retirement plans to meet your spending needs during your lifetime, and don’t ever need to tap into your tax-favored retirement accounts, except as required by law; or (2) you are spending as much as you care to during your lifetime, and any additional resources will end up in the hands of your beneficiaries after your death. While both categories of "wealthy" benefit from long-term savings, the latter category (the "really wealthy" (?)), derive a greater degree of benefit than the former.
Unfortunately, those two rules of thumb don’t nearly cover the whole waterfront. They still fail to address Paul Anonymous’ situation and that of most readers of this blog. Most of us are not wealthy, and are either at or too near retirement to make use of Rule #1. In that case, the only approach I can recommend is to do a full-blown long-term financial projection. Or, short of that, do what Paul Anonymous is doing and go with your gut instinct.
Labels:
Roth Savings,
Savings Buckets
Monday, June 22, 2009
Another Good Roth Conversion Issue
In a comment to June 18’s post, Paul Anonymous has raised another good issue. (Thank you, Paul—whoever you are—you are a veritable fount of good ideas for blog posts.)
Paul’s situation presents a tax-planning issue that comes up all the time, in many sizes and many variations. When is a short-term tax cost outweighed by a long-term benefit? The question is simple. The answer? Not so much.
Here’s Paul’s version of the issue. He plans to make $11,000 nondeductible IRA contribution for 2009 (between him and his spouse, one of whom has reached age 50). He will then convert all his IRAs to Roth IRAs in 2010, when the rules change and the Roth dam bursts. If he contributes the $11,000 now, the tax cost of his Roth conversion will go up on account of any investment earnings between now and the conversion. Paul expects that that Roth conversion tax cost will exceed the tax cost of enjoying those investment earnings outside the shelter of the IRA. Why? Because he intends to invest his $11,000 in stocks, and, at least for the time being, the tax rate on dividends (and long-term capital gain) is lower than the general tax rate that applies to Roth conversions.
(An aside here. Actually, the tax rate on a 2010 Roth conversion might in fact be lower after you factor in the special tax deal on 2010 Roth conversions, as described in February 28’s post. The value of delaying tax by a year and a half brings the effective tax rate down a bit. But for the sake of discussion, let’s assume the tax cost of converting those investment earnings to a Roth account exceeds the tax cost of earning dividends outside the IRA.)
So. Here’s the ubiquitous issue. Is it worth it to pay that extra tax to shift more dollars from your taxable account into your Roth IRA? What’s more powerful—the short-term savings or the long-term benefit?
(Before answering, here’s another aside. The amount at issue here is truly miniscule. In terms of making a meaningful contribution to his future retirement security, Paul is planning to do two big important things with very favorable long-term consequences. (1) He and his wife are contributing the maximum ($11,000 in their case) to their IRAs. (2) And they are planning to convert their traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs in 2010. Way to go, Paul! So why am I even discussing the relatively minor issue of whether he makes the contribution now or just before the Roth conversion? How much could possibly be at stake? $100 investment earnings over the next 7 months maybe? Why am I wasting electronic ink? Just because it’s interesting to me; that’s why. I really need to get a life.)
So, anyway, what’s the answer? Well, it depends on many factors, so there is no one right answer.
But in my experience, after doing untold numbers of projections with varying degrees of precision, I find that the long-term benefit of shifting that hypothetical $100 into the Roth account often exceed the short-term cost of paying a greater rate of tax on an extra $100 in 2010. Or, more precisely, on half in 2011 and half in 2012.
A bit more on this tomorrow.
Paul’s situation presents a tax-planning issue that comes up all the time, in many sizes and many variations. When is a short-term tax cost outweighed by a long-term benefit? The question is simple. The answer? Not so much.
Here’s Paul’s version of the issue. He plans to make $11,000 nondeductible IRA contribution for 2009 (between him and his spouse, one of whom has reached age 50). He will then convert all his IRAs to Roth IRAs in 2010, when the rules change and the Roth dam bursts. If he contributes the $11,000 now, the tax cost of his Roth conversion will go up on account of any investment earnings between now and the conversion. Paul expects that that Roth conversion tax cost will exceed the tax cost of enjoying those investment earnings outside the shelter of the IRA. Why? Because he intends to invest his $11,000 in stocks, and, at least for the time being, the tax rate on dividends (and long-term capital gain) is lower than the general tax rate that applies to Roth conversions.
(An aside here. Actually, the tax rate on a 2010 Roth conversion might in fact be lower after you factor in the special tax deal on 2010 Roth conversions, as described in February 28’s post. The value of delaying tax by a year and a half brings the effective tax rate down a bit. But for the sake of discussion, let’s assume the tax cost of converting those investment earnings to a Roth account exceeds the tax cost of earning dividends outside the IRA.)
So. Here’s the ubiquitous issue. Is it worth it to pay that extra tax to shift more dollars from your taxable account into your Roth IRA? What’s more powerful—the short-term savings or the long-term benefit?
(Before answering, here’s another aside. The amount at issue here is truly miniscule. In terms of making a meaningful contribution to his future retirement security, Paul is planning to do two big important things with very favorable long-term consequences. (1) He and his wife are contributing the maximum ($11,000 in their case) to their IRAs. (2) And they are planning to convert their traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs in 2010. Way to go, Paul! So why am I even discussing the relatively minor issue of whether he makes the contribution now or just before the Roth conversion? How much could possibly be at stake? $100 investment earnings over the next 7 months maybe? Why am I wasting electronic ink? Just because it’s interesting to me; that’s why. I really need to get a life.)
So, anyway, what’s the answer? Well, it depends on many factors, so there is no one right answer.
But in my experience, after doing untold numbers of projections with varying degrees of precision, I find that the long-term benefit of shifting that hypothetical $100 into the Roth account often exceed the short-term cost of paying a greater rate of tax on an extra $100 in 2010. Or, more precisely, on half in 2011 and half in 2012.
A bit more on this tomorrow.
Labels:
Roth Savings,
Savings Buckets
Thursday, June 18, 2009
Roth Conversion Questions
In a comment to May 15’s post, Paul Anonymous raises a number of questions about 2010 Roth IRA conversions. Good man, Paul, you're planning ahead! I’ll try to answer them.
Paul already has both a traditional and a Roth IRA. One question is whether you need to open a separate Roth IRA to hold the assets converted from a traditional IRA, or can you use the existing Roth IRA. The answer is that you don’t need to open a new Roth IRA. One acceptable method for converting a traditional IRA to a Roth is to transfer assets from an existing traditional IRA to an existing Roth IRA. That seems like the administratively easiest thing to do, rather than maintain two separate Roth IRA's needlessly. Although that won’t work if you want to keep the assets at different institutions. Then you’ll of course need separate IRAs.
Paul next asks a question about the wisdom of maintaining a small traditional IRA. Here’s the scenario. Paul apparently intends to convert all (or virtually all) of his traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs. He doesn’t say that explicitly, but that appears to be his plan. And apparently he does not expect to meet the qualification requirements for annual Roth IRA contributions—too much Adjusted Gross Income perhaps. So, looking to the future—2011 and beyond—Paul is planning to make annual traditional IRA contributions and then immediately turn around and convert them to Roth IRAs. Good planning! But that raises the question of whether he should leave some money in a traditional IRA—perhaps a nominal amount—so he doesn’t have to re-open a new traditional IRA every year. I think that’s a terrific idea, as it saves the administrative headache of opening a new account every year--a process that has gotten increasingly burdensome. Keep just enough in the traditional IRA to minimize administrative fees, and then convert the rest to a Roth IRA.
Paul plans to delay his 2009 nondeductible traditional IRA contribution until early 2010. At that point, he will make both his 2009 and 2010 nondeductible traditional IRA contributions, and then immediately turn around and convert them to Roth IRAs. Paul’s thinking is that by delaying the 2009 contribution, he will avoid investment earnings on that amount and reduce the tax cost of converting his whole traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs.
Not so fast, Paulie. I’ve got to disagree with your analysis there. If you keep your $5,000 in your taxable account for the rest of 2009, aren’t you going to earn some returns inside your taxable account—say $50? And then won’t that therefore generate an income tax. In fact, if you invest in interest-bearing investments, the tax you save on the Roth conversion will exactly equal the tax you’ll owe on your taxable investment earnings, so there will be no tax savings at all, plus you will have lost the opportunity to house the $50 inside that most valuable Roth investment environment. Even if you invest in equities, the earnings on which enjoy lower tax rates, the long run benefits of having the $50 inside the Roth environment easily outweigh the short-term detriment of paying a greater Roth conversion tax than a corresponding income tax on the $50 investment earnings. So if I were Paul, I would make my 2009 traditional IRA contribution now, and thereby divert that hypothetical $50 from my taxable bucket to my tax-exempt bucket.
An aside here. It appears that Paul is planning to convert virtually all his traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs in 2010. Would it still be his best strategy to make a 2009 nondeductible IRA contribution if he were planning to convert only a portion of his IRA's to Roths—let’s say 25% of his traditional IRAs? That’s a tougher question. Because then he would only get to recover 25% of his nondeductible contributions tax-free in 2010, and he’d have to wait until later years to recover the remaining 75%. Let’s say he makes a $5,000 nondeductible traditional IRA contribution in 2009, and then converts 25% of his traditional IRAs to a Roth in 2010. The amount he pays tax on is reduced by 25% of his cumulative non-deductible contributions, including the one from 2009. So he contributes $5,000—no deduction—and ends up paying a Roth conversion tax on $3,750. He’s just increased his taxable income by $3,750; he’ll eventually recover the other $3,750 tax-free, but it will take years for that to happen. Is that good planning? I don’t know. I suspect it is, but I think the issue needs some closer study. Look for more on this question in a future post.
Paul already has both a traditional and a Roth IRA. One question is whether you need to open a separate Roth IRA to hold the assets converted from a traditional IRA, or can you use the existing Roth IRA. The answer is that you don’t need to open a new Roth IRA. One acceptable method for converting a traditional IRA to a Roth is to transfer assets from an existing traditional IRA to an existing Roth IRA. That seems like the administratively easiest thing to do, rather than maintain two separate Roth IRA's needlessly. Although that won’t work if you want to keep the assets at different institutions. Then you’ll of course need separate IRAs.
Paul next asks a question about the wisdom of maintaining a small traditional IRA. Here’s the scenario. Paul apparently intends to convert all (or virtually all) of his traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs. He doesn’t say that explicitly, but that appears to be his plan. And apparently he does not expect to meet the qualification requirements for annual Roth IRA contributions—too much Adjusted Gross Income perhaps. So, looking to the future—2011 and beyond—Paul is planning to make annual traditional IRA contributions and then immediately turn around and convert them to Roth IRAs. Good planning! But that raises the question of whether he should leave some money in a traditional IRA—perhaps a nominal amount—so he doesn’t have to re-open a new traditional IRA every year. I think that’s a terrific idea, as it saves the administrative headache of opening a new account every year--a process that has gotten increasingly burdensome. Keep just enough in the traditional IRA to minimize administrative fees, and then convert the rest to a Roth IRA.
Paul plans to delay his 2009 nondeductible traditional IRA contribution until early 2010. At that point, he will make both his 2009 and 2010 nondeductible traditional IRA contributions, and then immediately turn around and convert them to Roth IRAs. Paul’s thinking is that by delaying the 2009 contribution, he will avoid investment earnings on that amount and reduce the tax cost of converting his whole traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs.
Not so fast, Paulie. I’ve got to disagree with your analysis there. If you keep your $5,000 in your taxable account for the rest of 2009, aren’t you going to earn some returns inside your taxable account—say $50? And then won’t that therefore generate an income tax. In fact, if you invest in interest-bearing investments, the tax you save on the Roth conversion will exactly equal the tax you’ll owe on your taxable investment earnings, so there will be no tax savings at all, plus you will have lost the opportunity to house the $50 inside that most valuable Roth investment environment. Even if you invest in equities, the earnings on which enjoy lower tax rates, the long run benefits of having the $50 inside the Roth environment easily outweigh the short-term detriment of paying a greater Roth conversion tax than a corresponding income tax on the $50 investment earnings. So if I were Paul, I would make my 2009 traditional IRA contribution now, and thereby divert that hypothetical $50 from my taxable bucket to my tax-exempt bucket.
An aside here. It appears that Paul is planning to convert virtually all his traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs in 2010. Would it still be his best strategy to make a 2009 nondeductible IRA contribution if he were planning to convert only a portion of his IRA's to Roths—let’s say 25% of his traditional IRAs? That’s a tougher question. Because then he would only get to recover 25% of his nondeductible contributions tax-free in 2010, and he’d have to wait until later years to recover the remaining 75%. Let’s say he makes a $5,000 nondeductible traditional IRA contribution in 2009, and then converts 25% of his traditional IRAs to a Roth in 2010. The amount he pays tax on is reduced by 25% of his cumulative non-deductible contributions, including the one from 2009. So he contributes $5,000—no deduction—and ends up paying a Roth conversion tax on $3,750. He’s just increased his taxable income by $3,750; he’ll eventually recover the other $3,750 tax-free, but it will take years for that to happen. Is that good planning? I don’t know. I suspect it is, but I think the issue needs some closer study. Look for more on this question in a future post.
Labels:
Roth Savings,
Savings Buckets
Wednesday, June 17, 2009
Keeping Track of Nondeductible IRA Contributions
In a comment to Monday’s post, David raises a question about keeping track of non-deductible contributions to a traditional IRA. He asks if his IRA manager should be expected to keep track of this for him.
The short answer is “no.” Your IRA trustee or custodian—or for that matter, any other financial institution involved with your IRA, such as an investment advisor or mutual fund company—is not obligated to keep track of your nondeductible contributions. Not only are they not obligated to do this, they can’t do it, since the facts that determine whether a given IRA contribution is deductible or not is beyond their knowledge. They don’t know about your status as an active participant in your employer’s retirement plan; nor do they know your AGI. So if you think you’ve lost track of your nondeductible contributions, you can’t look to them for help.
(By the way, the rules for determining whether a traditional IRA contribution is deductible or not—which are way more complicated than they need to be—are summarized in February 14’s post.)
But wait! All is not lost! The only one who can keep track of your cumulative nondeductible traditional IRA contributions is you. And chances are pretty good you’ve done so, even if you don’t remember. Here’s why. Whenever you make a nondeductible traditional IRA contribution, you’re required to file a Form 8606 with your tax return for that year. And that form picks up your cumulative nondeductible contributions from prior years and makes you keep a running total. So all you have to do is find your tax return from the most recent year in which you made a nondeductible contribution, and, voila!, there it is. You don’t have to comb through all prior years’ returns—just the most recent one.
And then when you start taking distributions later in life, the same Form 8606 helps you (actually, makes you) keep track of how much of your distribution is tax-free, and how much you have left to recover tax-free in later years.
If you can’t find your tax return for the year you last made a nondeductible contribution, all is not lost. Maybe your accountant kept a copy. Or if you used tax preparation software, maybe the software kept track of it on your computer. I know from personal experience that Turbo-Tax keeps a running record of it, and carries it forward from year to year.
One other point David raised that I want to touch on. In his comment he asks if he should have expected his IRA manager to have “segregated” his nondeductible contributions. Segregating your nondeductible contributions is neither necessary nor at all helpful. That’s because, as described in February 15’s post, when it comes time to take distributions and enjoy some tax-free distributions, IRS rules force you to aggregate all your traditional IRAs in figuring the amount that’s tax-free. Segregating them into one IRA does you no good.
’Til manana.
The short answer is “no.” Your IRA trustee or custodian—or for that matter, any other financial institution involved with your IRA, such as an investment advisor or mutual fund company—is not obligated to keep track of your nondeductible contributions. Not only are they not obligated to do this, they can’t do it, since the facts that determine whether a given IRA contribution is deductible or not is beyond their knowledge. They don’t know about your status as an active participant in your employer’s retirement plan; nor do they know your AGI. So if you think you’ve lost track of your nondeductible contributions, you can’t look to them for help.
(By the way, the rules for determining whether a traditional IRA contribution is deductible or not—which are way more complicated than they need to be—are summarized in February 14’s post.)
But wait! All is not lost! The only one who can keep track of your cumulative nondeductible traditional IRA contributions is you. And chances are pretty good you’ve done so, even if you don’t remember. Here’s why. Whenever you make a nondeductible traditional IRA contribution, you’re required to file a Form 8606 with your tax return for that year. And that form picks up your cumulative nondeductible contributions from prior years and makes you keep a running total. So all you have to do is find your tax return from the most recent year in which you made a nondeductible contribution, and, voila!, there it is. You don’t have to comb through all prior years’ returns—just the most recent one.
And then when you start taking distributions later in life, the same Form 8606 helps you (actually, makes you) keep track of how much of your distribution is tax-free, and how much you have left to recover tax-free in later years.
If you can’t find your tax return for the year you last made a nondeductible contribution, all is not lost. Maybe your accountant kept a copy. Or if you used tax preparation software, maybe the software kept track of it on your computer. I know from personal experience that Turbo-Tax keeps a running record of it, and carries it forward from year to year.
One other point David raised that I want to touch on. In his comment he asks if he should have expected his IRA manager to have “segregated” his nondeductible contributions. Segregating your nondeductible contributions is neither necessary nor at all helpful. That’s because, as described in February 15’s post, when it comes time to take distributions and enjoy some tax-free distributions, IRS rules force you to aggregate all your traditional IRAs in figuring the amount that’s tax-free. Segregating them into one IRA does you no good.
’Til manana.
Labels:
Savings Buckets
Monday, June 15, 2009
Losses in Retirement Accounts
I’m back from vacation! Actually I was back a couple of weeks ago, but I was a bit lazy about getting back to The Two Legged Stool. But I’m here now.
I thought I would restart by responding to a couple of comments. First Paul. In his comment to the May 15 post, Anonymous (aka Paul) raises a couple of issues. One of them deals with losses inside a nondeductible IRA. Paul wonders if you can deduct up to $3,000 of losses that you have incurred inside your nondeductible Individual Retirement Account.
You can’t directly deduct losses that occur inside your IRA. Instead, you indirectly get the tax benefit of your losses by having that much less to distribute during your retirement years and therefore reporting that much less taxable income. Remember, everything that goes on inside your IRA is generally irrelevant for income tax purposes. You don’t (yet) pay taxes on interest or dividends; you don’t pay taxes on any capital gains; and you don’t get to deduct any capital losses.
There is one possibility for deducting a tax loss in a nondeductible IRA, but it’s very unusual and I hope it never happens to you. Here it is. When you are at the point of taking out the last dollars from all your traditional IRAs, deductible and nondeductible, if you still have any nondeductible contributions left that you haven’t yet deducted (also sometimes called “basis”), and your losses have been so great over your lifetime that your basis actually exceeds the amount remaining in your IRA, then you can take a tax loss for the difference. I hope this doesn’t happen to you! Picture how unusual it is. It could only happen at the waning years of your life when you’re ready to completely deplete your IRA. (It could also happen sooner if you convert all your traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs.) And your losses would have had to have been pretty bad to exceed all your income and gains during your lifetime. And you have to look at all your traditional IRAs in the aggregate when figuring whether you have a net loss or not. So overall it’s pretty unusual to realize an actual net deductible loss on your IRA.
It's good to be back.
I thought I would restart by responding to a couple of comments. First Paul. In his comment to the May 15 post, Anonymous (aka Paul) raises a couple of issues. One of them deals with losses inside a nondeductible IRA. Paul wonders if you can deduct up to $3,000 of losses that you have incurred inside your nondeductible Individual Retirement Account.
You can’t directly deduct losses that occur inside your IRA. Instead, you indirectly get the tax benefit of your losses by having that much less to distribute during your retirement years and therefore reporting that much less taxable income. Remember, everything that goes on inside your IRA is generally irrelevant for income tax purposes. You don’t (yet) pay taxes on interest or dividends; you don’t pay taxes on any capital gains; and you don’t get to deduct any capital losses.
There is one possibility for deducting a tax loss in a nondeductible IRA, but it’s very unusual and I hope it never happens to you. Here it is. When you are at the point of taking out the last dollars from all your traditional IRAs, deductible and nondeductible, if you still have any nondeductible contributions left that you haven’t yet deducted (also sometimes called “basis”), and your losses have been so great over your lifetime that your basis actually exceeds the amount remaining in your IRA, then you can take a tax loss for the difference. I hope this doesn’t happen to you! Picture how unusual it is. It could only happen at the waning years of your life when you’re ready to completely deplete your IRA. (It could also happen sooner if you convert all your traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs.) And your losses would have had to have been pretty bad to exceed all your income and gains during your lifetime. And you have to look at all your traditional IRAs in the aggregate when figuring whether you have a net loss or not. So overall it’s pretty unusual to realize an actual net deductible loss on your IRA.
It's good to be back.
Labels:
Savings Buckets
Friday, May 8, 2009
Timing of Roth Conversion
In a comment to May 4’s post, “Financial Planner Atlanta” (if that’s your real name) raised a good question. How does the timing of a 2010 distribution from a 401(k) plan and follow-up IRA rollover affect the decision to convert a traditional Individual Retirement Account to a Roth IRA?
The fortunate answer is that the timing of the rollover is irrelevant to the tax cost of converting a pre-existing IRA to a Roth IRA.
Let’s say the IRA is worth $200,000 and the 401(k) is worth $1,000,000. By rolling over the $1,000,000 to a traditional IRA, that $1,000,000 is excluded from your Adjusted Gross Income and from your taxable income. So when you add the $100,000 IRA balance to your other 2010 income to figure your tax cost, the $1,000,000 doesn’t appear anywhere or affect any of your tax calculations.
And the same is true if you elect to have the $200,000 taxed in 2011 and 2012, $100,000 each year. The $1,000,000 rollover disappears from those tax calculations as well.
And the same is true whether the 401(k) rollover occurs before or after the Roth IRA conversion. Or even if the Roth IRA conversion happens during the up-to-60-day period between when the 401(k) plan distributes the $1,000,000 and you roll it into your IRA.
Finally, once the dust settles on the rollover, you have th rest of the year to decide if you want to Rothificate some of it in addition to the original $200,000. At a greater tax cost, of course.
I hope that answers the question.
The fortunate answer is that the timing of the rollover is irrelevant to the tax cost of converting a pre-existing IRA to a Roth IRA.
Let’s say the IRA is worth $200,000 and the 401(k) is worth $1,000,000. By rolling over the $1,000,000 to a traditional IRA, that $1,000,000 is excluded from your Adjusted Gross Income and from your taxable income. So when you add the $100,000 IRA balance to your other 2010 income to figure your tax cost, the $1,000,000 doesn’t appear anywhere or affect any of your tax calculations.
And the same is true if you elect to have the $200,000 taxed in 2011 and 2012, $100,000 each year. The $1,000,000 rollover disappears from those tax calculations as well.
And the same is true whether the 401(k) rollover occurs before or after the Roth IRA conversion. Or even if the Roth IRA conversion happens during the up-to-60-day period between when the 401(k) plan distributes the $1,000,000 and you roll it into your IRA.
Finally, once the dust settles on the rollover, you have th rest of the year to decide if you want to Rothificate some of it in addition to the original $200,000. At a greater tax cost, of course.
I hope that answers the question.
Labels:
Roth Savings,
Savings Buckets
Tuesday, May 5, 2009
State Taxation of Retirement Distributions
How will your state tax your retirement distributions? That’s a cost which you will need to take into account as you set your savings goal.
Most states have their own income tax. A few states, like Florida, have no income tax. (What fuels their government? Sunshine? ) Of the states that do impose an income tax, many have chosen the expedient scheme of piggy-backing onto the federal income tax system by starting the state tax calculation with the income and deduction figures from your federal tax return, and then adding and subtracting a few adjustments from there. So in these states, if a dollar of distribution from a retirement account is taxable for federal purposes, it will be equally taxable for state purposes, at least initially. And in these states, if—as with a well-timed Roth IRA distribution—it’s not taxable for federal income tax purposes, then it won’t be taxable for state income tax purposes either.
Some states have enacted a special benefit for their senior citizens. New York, for example, exempts up to $20,000 of otherwise taxable retirement income from state tax. Thank you, New York!
Imagine this scenario, which is not atypical. You work all your life in a high tax state, like New York or California. During all those years you are earning contributions to retirement accounts which are not being taxed. Some contributions are made by your employer, and some are made by you (think 401(k)). These contributions have gone into the Tax Time Machine, as described in January 29’s post. Then you retire to sunny Florida—which has no income tax—and you start taking distributions from these accounts. “Wait a minute,” says the state of California, “you earned those dollars when you were working here. We want to collect some of that tax revenue, no matter where you live. We’re coming to get you!”
Can California do that? No, they can’t. They tried to, a number of years ago, and in response Congress passed a law making it illegal for a state to tax retirement plan distributions to residents of another state, even if the non-resident had earned the contributions while living and working in the taxing state. This law applies to tax-favored retirement accounts, like IRA’s and 401(k)’s, but it doesn’t apply to many non-qualified deferred compensation plans.
(What’s a non-qualified deferred compensation plan? It’s a kind of retirement plan only available to highly paid employees. If you’ve got one, you know what it is.)
So as you do your planning, and project your tax costs, pay a bit of attention to your state’s taxing scheme.
Most states have their own income tax. A few states, like Florida, have no income tax. (What fuels their government? Sunshine? ) Of the states that do impose an income tax, many have chosen the expedient scheme of piggy-backing onto the federal income tax system by starting the state tax calculation with the income and deduction figures from your federal tax return, and then adding and subtracting a few adjustments from there. So in these states, if a dollar of distribution from a retirement account is taxable for federal purposes, it will be equally taxable for state purposes, at least initially. And in these states, if—as with a well-timed Roth IRA distribution—it’s not taxable for federal income tax purposes, then it won’t be taxable for state income tax purposes either.
Some states have enacted a special benefit for their senior citizens. New York, for example, exempts up to $20,000 of otherwise taxable retirement income from state tax. Thank you, New York!
Imagine this scenario, which is not atypical. You work all your life in a high tax state, like New York or California. During all those years you are earning contributions to retirement accounts which are not being taxed. Some contributions are made by your employer, and some are made by you (think 401(k)). These contributions have gone into the Tax Time Machine, as described in January 29’s post. Then you retire to sunny Florida—which has no income tax—and you start taking distributions from these accounts. “Wait a minute,” says the state of California, “you earned those dollars when you were working here. We want to collect some of that tax revenue, no matter where you live. We’re coming to get you!”
Can California do that? No, they can’t. They tried to, a number of years ago, and in response Congress passed a law making it illegal for a state to tax retirement plan distributions to residents of another state, even if the non-resident had earned the contributions while living and working in the taxing state. This law applies to tax-favored retirement accounts, like IRA’s and 401(k)’s, but it doesn’t apply to many non-qualified deferred compensation plans.
(What’s a non-qualified deferred compensation plan? It’s a kind of retirement plan only available to highly paid employees. If you’ve got one, you know what it is.)
So as you do your planning, and project your tax costs, pay a bit of attention to your state’s taxing scheme.
Labels:
Retirement Planning,
Savings Buckets
Saturday, April 25, 2009
Refundable vs. Nonrefundable Saver’s Credit
Yesterday’s post described the Saver’s Credit, a taxpayer-paid matching contribution designed to encourage and assist low income workers to save for their retirement. In a thoughtful comment, David highlighted the purpose of the Saver's Credit, which is to asist low-income workers in saving for their own retirement.
Which leads me to focus on one particular feature of the Saver's Credit: it’s a nonrefundable credit. That’s tax jargon for a credit that is limited to your tax liability. A nonrefundable credit can only operate to reduce your tax liability. If your potential credit is a dollar more than your tax liability, you don’t get that extra dollar.
There’s currently a bill recently introduced into the House of Representatives by Congressman Pomeroy (H.R. 1961) that would turn the Saver’s Credit into a refundable credit. If your potential Saver’s Credit exceeds your tax liability for the year, the taxpayers give you a refund anyway—although “refund” is a poor choice of words, since the dollars would come from other taxpayers.
What is the point of drawing a bright line at your tax liability? Opponents of refundable credits call it welfare, since the refundable part comes from other taxpayers. If you limit the credit to tax liability, it’s easier to characterize it as a tax reduction. (“Welfare,” “tax reduction.” Words are really loaded, aren’t they?) Proponents of refundable credits note the arbitrary nature of the line that’s being drawn at the taxpayer’s tax liability. If she’s engaging in the favored activity that generates the credit, why draw a line at her tax liability? Particularly as the complexity of the Tax Code, with all its other deductions, exemptions and credits, makes that line increasingly arbitrary.
It’s instructive to note what other credits in the Tax Code are refundable. What activities are so favored by Congress that they are willing to have other taxpayers support the activity? The big one is the earned income credit, which constitutes taxpayer help for the working poor. There are also a couple of narrowly targeted credits aimed at farmers with high fuel costs and some unemployed individuals who need help with their health insurance costs. Most other credits—the child tax credit, adoption assistance, dependent care, the list is a long one—are nonrefundable. Congress just hates stepping over that line.
So what do I think? (Actually, nobody really asked me, but I have the floor.) I favor making the Saver’s Credit refundable. In my view, helping low income workers save for their retirement falls into the same category as the earned income credit for the working poor. They’re doing everything society wants and encourages them to do, yet often through no fault of their own they need help making ends meet. They’re exactly the ones the rest of us, through our tax dollars, ought to encourage, assist and support. They're the productive ones, the good guys.
Besides, if you look at the way the Tax Code is structured, you get the definite sense that deductions and credits serve fundamentally different purposes. Deductions are generally aimed at figuring the "right" measure of your ability to pay income tax. Credits, on the other hand, are designed to encourage specific activities; they are not germane to calculating your fair share of the country's overall need for tax revenue.
So what do you think? I’d like to know. Send me an email at TheTwoLeggedStool@gmail.com. Or, better, post a comment.
Which leads me to focus on one particular feature of the Saver's Credit: it’s a nonrefundable credit. That’s tax jargon for a credit that is limited to your tax liability. A nonrefundable credit can only operate to reduce your tax liability. If your potential credit is a dollar more than your tax liability, you don’t get that extra dollar.
There’s currently a bill recently introduced into the House of Representatives by Congressman Pomeroy (H.R. 1961) that would turn the Saver’s Credit into a refundable credit. If your potential Saver’s Credit exceeds your tax liability for the year, the taxpayers give you a refund anyway—although “refund” is a poor choice of words, since the dollars would come from other taxpayers.
What is the point of drawing a bright line at your tax liability? Opponents of refundable credits call it welfare, since the refundable part comes from other taxpayers. If you limit the credit to tax liability, it’s easier to characterize it as a tax reduction. (“Welfare,” “tax reduction.” Words are really loaded, aren’t they?) Proponents of refundable credits note the arbitrary nature of the line that’s being drawn at the taxpayer’s tax liability. If she’s engaging in the favored activity that generates the credit, why draw a line at her tax liability? Particularly as the complexity of the Tax Code, with all its other deductions, exemptions and credits, makes that line increasingly arbitrary.
It’s instructive to note what other credits in the Tax Code are refundable. What activities are so favored by Congress that they are willing to have other taxpayers support the activity? The big one is the earned income credit, which constitutes taxpayer help for the working poor. There are also a couple of narrowly targeted credits aimed at farmers with high fuel costs and some unemployed individuals who need help with their health insurance costs. Most other credits—the child tax credit, adoption assistance, dependent care, the list is a long one—are nonrefundable. Congress just hates stepping over that line.
So what do I think? (Actually, nobody really asked me, but I have the floor.) I favor making the Saver’s Credit refundable. In my view, helping low income workers save for their retirement falls into the same category as the earned income credit for the working poor. They’re doing everything society wants and encourages them to do, yet often through no fault of their own they need help making ends meet. They’re exactly the ones the rest of us, through our tax dollars, ought to encourage, assist and support. They're the productive ones, the good guys.
Besides, if you look at the way the Tax Code is structured, you get the definite sense that deductions and credits serve fundamentally different purposes. Deductions are generally aimed at figuring the "right" measure of your ability to pay income tax. Credits, on the other hand, are designed to encourage specific activities; they are not germane to calculating your fair share of the country's overall need for tax revenue.
So what do you think? I’d like to know. Send me an email at TheTwoLeggedStool@gmail.com. Or, better, post a comment.
Labels:
Public Policy,
Savings Buckets
Friday, April 24, 2009
The Saver’s Credit
Your federal government wants you to save for your own retirement. In fact, they want it so much they are willing to give you a matching contribution of sorts. But only if you have low income. In other words, you can get a reward for saving only if you are too poor to afford to save. Oh well.
Notwithstanding that Catch 22, there are plenty of people who can afford to save for retirement and who meet the requirements to benefit. Here are the ground rules.
• This governmental benefit comes in the form of a tax credit. It’s not an actual matching contribution, in that it’s not added to your retirement account, like your employer’s 401(k) match. Rather, it comes to you in the form of reduced income tax liability (or an increased refund) come April 15. So your tax credit ought to free up an equivalent number of other dollars, enabling you to increase the amount you otherwise were able to contribute to a retirement plan. Economically, the tax credit can act just like a matching contribution. That’s the theory anyway.
• The tax credit is not a refundable credit. That means it is limited to no more than your income tax liability for the year. Unfortunately, this takes a lot of low-income people out of the running.
• You become entitled to the credit by contributing to a tax-favored retirement plan of some kind, either an Individual Retirement Account, a Roth IRA, or your own contribution to a 401(k) plan, 403(b) Plan, 457 Plan, or SIMPLE IRA Plan.
• The maximum contribution that’s matched is $2,000 per year.
• The credit percentage, or matching percentage if you will, is based on your Adjusted Gross Income. The lower your Adjusted Gross Income, the higher your matching percentage. It starts out at a healthy 50% match if your AGI (in 2009) is under $16,500 ($33,000 if married), and ratchets down to 10% if your AGI is under $27,750 ($55,500 if married). AGI above those amounts, and you’re out of luck. No credit for you!
• To avoid abuses, your contribution that otherwise entitles you to a tax credit is reduced by any recent distributions you took from a retirement plan—during the year of your contribution or the following year up to the due date of your tax return, or either of the two preceding years.
• To avoid even sneakier abuses, your matched contribution is also reduced by recent retirement plan distributions taken by your spouse. They’re up to your tricks, you rascal.
• Those under age 18, full time students, and those claimed by a parent as a dependent cannot qualify for the saver’s credit.
• You claim the credit by filing a Form 8880 with your tax return.
If you meet all these requirements, you have extra reasons to strive to put away a little something for the future.
Notwithstanding that Catch 22, there are plenty of people who can afford to save for retirement and who meet the requirements to benefit. Here are the ground rules.
• This governmental benefit comes in the form of a tax credit. It’s not an actual matching contribution, in that it’s not added to your retirement account, like your employer’s 401(k) match. Rather, it comes to you in the form of reduced income tax liability (or an increased refund) come April 15. So your tax credit ought to free up an equivalent number of other dollars, enabling you to increase the amount you otherwise were able to contribute to a retirement plan. Economically, the tax credit can act just like a matching contribution. That’s the theory anyway.
• The tax credit is not a refundable credit. That means it is limited to no more than your income tax liability for the year. Unfortunately, this takes a lot of low-income people out of the running.
• You become entitled to the credit by contributing to a tax-favored retirement plan of some kind, either an Individual Retirement Account, a Roth IRA, or your own contribution to a 401(k) plan, 403(b) Plan, 457 Plan, or SIMPLE IRA Plan.
• The maximum contribution that’s matched is $2,000 per year.
• The credit percentage, or matching percentage if you will, is based on your Adjusted Gross Income. The lower your Adjusted Gross Income, the higher your matching percentage. It starts out at a healthy 50% match if your AGI (in 2009) is under $16,500 ($33,000 if married), and ratchets down to 10% if your AGI is under $27,750 ($55,500 if married). AGI above those amounts, and you’re out of luck. No credit for you!
• To avoid abuses, your contribution that otherwise entitles you to a tax credit is reduced by any recent distributions you took from a retirement plan—during the year of your contribution or the following year up to the due date of your tax return, or either of the two preceding years.
• To avoid even sneakier abuses, your matched contribution is also reduced by recent retirement plan distributions taken by your spouse. They’re up to your tricks, you rascal.
• Those under age 18, full time students, and those claimed by a parent as a dependent cannot qualify for the saver’s credit.
• You claim the credit by filing a Form 8880 with your tax return.
If you meet all these requirements, you have extra reasons to strive to put away a little something for the future.
Labels:
Savings Buckets
Thursday, April 23, 2009
Roth Accounts for Federal Employees?
Riddle: What does a Roth 401(k) account have to do with smoking cigarettes?
Answer: Read on.
I am a big fan of Roth savings, as expressed in a number of prior posts; particularly for those who would like to save more in their tax-favored retirement plans, but are prevented from doing so because of limitations in the Tax Code. So Roth 401(k) accounts, potentially available since 2006, have been a great recent development, since they carry no income-related restrictions. But Roth 401(k) accounts are only an option if your employer chooses to make them available.
What about federal employees? Federal employees are covered by the Thrift Savings Plan, a 401(k)-like retirement savings plan. Unfortunately, there is no provision for Roth accounts in the Thrift Savings Plan, so federal employees are out of luck.
But that may change soon. The Board governing the Thrift Savings Plan has this week endorsed a proposal to add a Roth option to the TSP. That’s the good news. Now here’s the bad news: actually adding such a feature requires legislation. The House of Representatives passed a bill adding Roth accounts to the TSP, but the Senate and President also have to act.
Now back to the riddle: What does Roth saving have to do with cigarette smoking? In the real world, nothing. In Bizarro congressional world, apparently they are deeply related in ways the rest of us can’t begin to fathom. The provision for adding a Roth savings option to the TSP is included in a bill to give the FDA authority to regulate tobacco. So whether federal employees get a favorable retirement saving opportunity may hinge on how your senator feels about giving the FDA the power to regulate tobacco.
Federal employees, join the rest of us. We in private industry only get Roth opportunities if our employers choose to add it to our 401(k) plans; you only get them if your senator believes in federal regulation of tobacco.
Answer: Read on.
I am a big fan of Roth savings, as expressed in a number of prior posts; particularly for those who would like to save more in their tax-favored retirement plans, but are prevented from doing so because of limitations in the Tax Code. So Roth 401(k) accounts, potentially available since 2006, have been a great recent development, since they carry no income-related restrictions. But Roth 401(k) accounts are only an option if your employer chooses to make them available.
What about federal employees? Federal employees are covered by the Thrift Savings Plan, a 401(k)-like retirement savings plan. Unfortunately, there is no provision for Roth accounts in the Thrift Savings Plan, so federal employees are out of luck.
But that may change soon. The Board governing the Thrift Savings Plan has this week endorsed a proposal to add a Roth option to the TSP. That’s the good news. Now here’s the bad news: actually adding such a feature requires legislation. The House of Representatives passed a bill adding Roth accounts to the TSP, but the Senate and President also have to act.
Now back to the riddle: What does Roth saving have to do with cigarette smoking? In the real world, nothing. In Bizarro congressional world, apparently they are deeply related in ways the rest of us can’t begin to fathom. The provision for adding a Roth savings option to the TSP is included in a bill to give the FDA authority to regulate tobacco. So whether federal employees get a favorable retirement saving opportunity may hinge on how your senator feels about giving the FDA the power to regulate tobacco.
Federal employees, join the rest of us. We in private industry only get Roth opportunities if our employers choose to add it to our 401(k) plans; you only get them if your senator believes in federal regulation of tobacco.
Labels:
Roth Savings,
Savings Buckets
Monday, April 20, 2009
The Better Investor Savings Bucket
There are many nice tax savings features of tax-favored retirement accounts—Individual Retirement Accounts, Roth IRA’s, 401(k) Plans, etc. And I’ve written a large number of posts about them. One of the subtler benefits of tax-favored retirement accounts compared to taxable investment accounts is how they make you a better investor.
Think about it. When you have your savings in a taxable investment account, the income tax consequences taints every investment move you make (or neglect to make).
• You tend to prefer tax-exempt municipal bonds over treasury or corporate bonds—so you don’t have to pay federal income tax on the interest.
• You tend to prefer your own state’s municipal bonds over your neighboring state’s, so you don’t have to pay state income tax on the interest.
• You tend to prefer stocks over bonds so you can benefit from temporarily tax-free appreciation and lower-taxed capital gain instead of taxable interest.
• You tend to prefer growth stocks over dividend-paying stocks for the same reasons.
• You tend to hold onto stocks that have substantially appreciated to avoid triggering a whopping capital gain.
• For the same reason, you tend to avoid rebalancing your mix of stocks and bonds to get back to your desired asset allocation.
• You tend to hold onto recently purchased stocks for longer than you might otherwise wish so you can turn high-taxed short-term gain into low-taxed long-term gain.
• As you age, you tend to hold onto highly appreciated stocks so your family can benefit from the increase in tax basis that occurs at death. Which some days feels like it’s just around the corner, doesn't it?
• When your stocks lose value, you tend to sell them prematurely for no other reason than to benefit from the tax losses.
All of these distortions in your thinking and acting just melt away when your investments are in a tax-favored retirement account. The shelter of its tax-exemption allows you to make the right investment decisions untainted by extraneous tax consequences. Goodness knows it’s hard enough to do that without the Tax Code breathing down your neck.
Think about it. When you have your savings in a taxable investment account, the income tax consequences taints every investment move you make (or neglect to make).
• You tend to prefer tax-exempt municipal bonds over treasury or corporate bonds—so you don’t have to pay federal income tax on the interest.
• You tend to prefer your own state’s municipal bonds over your neighboring state’s, so you don’t have to pay state income tax on the interest.
• You tend to prefer stocks over bonds so you can benefit from temporarily tax-free appreciation and lower-taxed capital gain instead of taxable interest.
• You tend to prefer growth stocks over dividend-paying stocks for the same reasons.
• You tend to hold onto stocks that have substantially appreciated to avoid triggering a whopping capital gain.
• For the same reason, you tend to avoid rebalancing your mix of stocks and bonds to get back to your desired asset allocation.
• You tend to hold onto recently purchased stocks for longer than you might otherwise wish so you can turn high-taxed short-term gain into low-taxed long-term gain.
• As you age, you tend to hold onto highly appreciated stocks so your family can benefit from the increase in tax basis that occurs at death. Which some days feels like it’s just around the corner, doesn't it?
• When your stocks lose value, you tend to sell them prematurely for no other reason than to benefit from the tax losses.
All of these distortions in your thinking and acting just melt away when your investments are in a tax-favored retirement account. The shelter of its tax-exemption allows you to make the right investment decisions untainted by extraneous tax consequences. Goodness knows it’s hard enough to do that without the Tax Code breathing down your neck.
Labels:
Investments,
Savings Buckets
Sunday, April 19, 2009
Your Teenager’s Retirement Saving
Teenagers. Ya gotta love ‘em. It’s like having your own personal Linda Blair around the house. As long as you’ve got to get yourself and your kids through the high maintenance teenage years, you might as well impart some good habits along the way. Like acceptable hygiene. And retirement saving.
When they get that first summer or after-school job, they are going to have a lot of discretionary income—a lot compared to what they need and are used to. So there’s no better time than the teenage years for them to begin the saving habit—setting aside a portion of their working income in a savings bucket of one kind or another. Saving is like playing baseball or doing crossword puzzles or lifting weights or playing guitar—the more you do it, the better you get at it. It becomes second nature. So there’s no better time for a person to learn how to save than when she has her first taste of discretionary compensation.
You might even encourage your kids’ saving habit by subsidizing it. Maybe give them a dollar for every two they put away in a savings bucket, so they can continue to enjoy some of the consumption benefits of their hard-earned income. It’ll be like your own family matching contribution.
So what’s the best kind of savings bucket for a teenager? That’s a no-brainer. It’s the Roth IRA! Teenagers don’t have much income (except for Miley Cyrus) so they usually meet the qualification rules for contributing to a Roth IRA, as described in February 4’s post. And for a teenager, the tax cost of foregoing a deduction (had they instead contributed to a traditional IRA) is very small; maybe even zero. Then the dollars they put aside—and every dollar of investment earnings for the next 70 or 80 years—is totally tax-free. What a deal!
Now don’t you wish you were a teenager again so that you could start your own Roth IRA? When I was a teenager there was no such thing as IRA's or Roth IRA's. Or electricity. Or the wheel.
When they get that first summer or after-school job, they are going to have a lot of discretionary income—a lot compared to what they need and are used to. So there’s no better time than the teenage years for them to begin the saving habit—setting aside a portion of their working income in a savings bucket of one kind or another. Saving is like playing baseball or doing crossword puzzles or lifting weights or playing guitar—the more you do it, the better you get at it. It becomes second nature. So there’s no better time for a person to learn how to save than when she has her first taste of discretionary compensation.
You might even encourage your kids’ saving habit by subsidizing it. Maybe give them a dollar for every two they put away in a savings bucket, so they can continue to enjoy some of the consumption benefits of their hard-earned income. It’ll be like your own family matching contribution.
So what’s the best kind of savings bucket for a teenager? That’s a no-brainer. It’s the Roth IRA! Teenagers don’t have much income (except for Miley Cyrus) so they usually meet the qualification rules for contributing to a Roth IRA, as described in February 4’s post. And for a teenager, the tax cost of foregoing a deduction (had they instead contributed to a traditional IRA) is very small; maybe even zero. Then the dollars they put aside—and every dollar of investment earnings for the next 70 or 80 years—is totally tax-free. What a deal!
Now don’t you wish you were a teenager again so that you could start your own Roth IRA? When I was a teenager there was no such thing as IRA's or Roth IRA's. Or electricity. Or the wheel.
Labels:
Retirement Planning,
Roth Savings,
Savings Buckets
Saturday, March 28, 2009
Pros and Cons of Special Tax Treatment for Employer Stock
In the last two posts I discussed special tax treatment for employer stock distributed to you out of your company’s retirement plan—sometimes called NUA treatment. But maybe it’s not so special after all. As pointed out in yesterday’s post, rolling over the stock into an IRA precludes NUA treatment, and vice versa. So which will it be? Door Number One or Door Number Two? Pay a lower capital gain tax, or get (likely) greater tax deferral with an IRA rollover. This is the same broad category of question that arises in other guises. See, for example, March 23’s post.
The issue is made extra difficult because you face two uncertainties, rather than just one. Usually, the issue of short-term low tax vs. long-term tax deferral turns on projecting when you will have to take distributions from your IRA; which is governed by a combination of the required minimum distribution rules, and your need to meet your living expenses. But with NUA treatment another uncertainty is added to the mix. When will you want to sell the employer stock you received, not because you need the money, but because it no longer fits into your investment planning? When you worked for the company, you were all, like, “Rah, rah, rah. This stock is going up, up, up” That was then. Now you’re like, “Whoa! Too many eggs in one basket. I’d better diversify this puppy.” Think Enron.
So for reasons of diversification, one would expect (one would certainly hope) that you’ll be selling a good chunk of that stock soon. So where should that sale occur? Inside the tax-sheltered environment of your IRA, knowing you’ll eventually pay a higher tax as the proceeds are distributed? Or outside the IRA, where you pay a smaller capital gains tax upon sale, but likely earlier than you otherwise would have, and without the further advantage of investing the sale proceeds in a tax-exempt environment? And even if you don’t plan to sell a bunch of stock for diversification purposes, you still might have to sell a chunk of it to raise the cash to pay the tax on the part of the stock that’s not Net Unrealized Appreciation, i.e., the trustee’s cost basis.
It’s not easy. My rule of thumb is (and rules of thumb are always wrong), when in doubt, opt for the long-term benefits of the IRA, and forego the siren lure of the lower capital gain tax rate. Or just opt for NUA treatment on a small portion of the stock—the portion that you’re not going to shortly diversify—say, 5% of it—and roll over the balance into your IRA. But that’s just me.
The issue is made extra difficult because you face two uncertainties, rather than just one. Usually, the issue of short-term low tax vs. long-term tax deferral turns on projecting when you will have to take distributions from your IRA; which is governed by a combination of the required minimum distribution rules, and your need to meet your living expenses. But with NUA treatment another uncertainty is added to the mix. When will you want to sell the employer stock you received, not because you need the money, but because it no longer fits into your investment planning? When you worked for the company, you were all, like, “Rah, rah, rah. This stock is going up, up, up” That was then. Now you’re like, “Whoa! Too many eggs in one basket. I’d better diversify this puppy.” Think Enron.
So for reasons of diversification, one would expect (one would certainly hope) that you’ll be selling a good chunk of that stock soon. So where should that sale occur? Inside the tax-sheltered environment of your IRA, knowing you’ll eventually pay a higher tax as the proceeds are distributed? Or outside the IRA, where you pay a smaller capital gains tax upon sale, but likely earlier than you otherwise would have, and without the further advantage of investing the sale proceeds in a tax-exempt environment? And even if you don’t plan to sell a bunch of stock for diversification purposes, you still might have to sell a chunk of it to raise the cash to pay the tax on the part of the stock that’s not Net Unrealized Appreciation, i.e., the trustee’s cost basis.
It’s not easy. My rule of thumb is (and rules of thumb are always wrong), when in doubt, opt for the long-term benefits of the IRA, and forego the siren lure of the lower capital gain tax rate. Or just opt for NUA treatment on a small portion of the stock—the portion that you’re not going to shortly diversify—say, 5% of it—and roll over the balance into your IRA. But that’s just me.
Labels:
Investments,
Savings Buckets
Friday, March 27, 2009
Qualifying for Special Tax Treatment for Employer Stock
In yesterday’s post I described special tax treatment that applies to certain distributions of employer stock from your employer’s retirement plan. But I didn’t say how to qualify for this deal. Having dealt with the cart, I will now get back to the horse. What conditions do you have to meet to qualify? Here they are in a nutshell.
• The distribution must be from a qualified plan, i.e., a plan that meets all the arcane qualification requirements for tax-favored status under the Tax Code. That includes 401(k) plans, profit sharing plans, and money purchase pension plans. It does not include Individual Retirement Accounts, 403(b) plans and 457 plans.
• The sponsoring employer must be a corporation.
• Some or all of the distribution must be in the form of stock in the employer.
• The distribution must have been made after or on account of one of the following events:
• The qualified plan must distribute the entire balance of your account.
• If your employer maintains two or more plans of the same type, you must also receive the entire balance of your account under any qualified plan of the same type maintained by your employer.
That last requirement sounds pretty mystifying. It also gets to a question raised by a reader. Here’s a little bit of explanation. The Tax Code recognizes three “types” of qualified retirement plans for purposes of meeting that last requirement. They are: (i) pension plans, (ii) profit sharing plans, and (iii) stock bonus plans. (To make your life difficult, the IRS has said that a qualified plan might fall into two types at once.)
The specific question a reader asked, in a comment to February 19’s post, is which “type” does an ESOP fall into. That question is either easy to answer or it’s hard. An “ESOP,” or Employee Stock Ownership Plan, in the strict Tax Code-defined sense of the word, must either be a money purchase pension plan (unusual) or a stock bonus plan (more typical). It can’t be a profit sharing plan. Easy answer.
Now here’s the hard part. People often use the term “ESOP’ in a looser sense. Like Humpty Dumpty, they use words to mean what they want. And you might sometimes hear a profit sharing plan that’s designed to invest in employer stock referred to as an “ESOP” in which case it falls into the profit sharing type, just like a 401(k) plan. In that case, an employee would have to receive lump sum distributions from both the 401(k) plan and the Humpty Dumpty "ESOP" to qualify for NUA treatment. The bottom line: If you get a lump sum distribution from your employer’s “ESOP”, and the employer also maintains a 401(k) plan, better ask the employer whether the “ESOP” is a stock bonus plan, a profit sharing plan, or both.
One other clarification. In her comment, the reader slightly misstated the requirement in the last bullet point. She wrote, “it's my understanding that you must take a lump sum distribution from all qualified plans of that employer in the same calendar year in order to receive NUA treatment on the select shares. This includes pension, profit sharing and stock bonus plans.” That’s not quite right. You don’t need to take lump sum distributions from all qualified plans to be entitled to NUA treatment—just qualified plans of the same type. So if you get a lump sum distribution from a stock bonus plan, and leave your account sitting in the 401(k) profit sharing plan, you can still qualify for NUA treatment on the employer securities included in the stock bonus plan distribution.
Whew! I’m glad I cleared that up. I haven’t been able to sleep.
Tomorrow, I’ll discuss the pros and cons of taking NUA treatment.
• The distribution must be from a qualified plan, i.e., a plan that meets all the arcane qualification requirements for tax-favored status under the Tax Code. That includes 401(k) plans, profit sharing plans, and money purchase pension plans. It does not include Individual Retirement Accounts, 403(b) plans and 457 plans.
• The sponsoring employer must be a corporation.
• Some or all of the distribution must be in the form of stock in the employer.
• The distribution must have been made after or on account of one of the following events:
- On account of your death
- After you have attained age 59-1/2
- On account of your separation from service with the employer.
• The qualified plan must distribute the entire balance of your account.
• If your employer maintains two or more plans of the same type, you must also receive the entire balance of your account under any qualified plan of the same type maintained by your employer.
That last requirement sounds pretty mystifying. It also gets to a question raised by a reader. Here’s a little bit of explanation. The Tax Code recognizes three “types” of qualified retirement plans for purposes of meeting that last requirement. They are: (i) pension plans, (ii) profit sharing plans, and (iii) stock bonus plans. (To make your life difficult, the IRS has said that a qualified plan might fall into two types at once.)
The specific question a reader asked, in a comment to February 19’s post, is which “type” does an ESOP fall into. That question is either easy to answer or it’s hard. An “ESOP,” or Employee Stock Ownership Plan, in the strict Tax Code-defined sense of the word, must either be a money purchase pension plan (unusual) or a stock bonus plan (more typical). It can’t be a profit sharing plan. Easy answer.
Now here’s the hard part. People often use the term “ESOP’ in a looser sense. Like Humpty Dumpty, they use words to mean what they want. And you might sometimes hear a profit sharing plan that’s designed to invest in employer stock referred to as an “ESOP” in which case it falls into the profit sharing type, just like a 401(k) plan. In that case, an employee would have to receive lump sum distributions from both the 401(k) plan and the Humpty Dumpty "ESOP" to qualify for NUA treatment. The bottom line: If you get a lump sum distribution from your employer’s “ESOP”, and the employer also maintains a 401(k) plan, better ask the employer whether the “ESOP” is a stock bonus plan, a profit sharing plan, or both.
One other clarification. In her comment, the reader slightly misstated the requirement in the last bullet point. She wrote, “it's my understanding that you must take a lump sum distribution from all qualified plans of that employer in the same calendar year in order to receive NUA treatment on the select shares. This includes pension, profit sharing and stock bonus plans.” That’s not quite right. You don’t need to take lump sum distributions from all qualified plans to be entitled to NUA treatment—just qualified plans of the same type. So if you get a lump sum distribution from a stock bonus plan, and leave your account sitting in the 401(k) profit sharing plan, you can still qualify for NUA treatment on the employer securities included in the stock bonus plan distribution.
Whew! I’m glad I cleared that up. I haven’t been able to sleep.
Tomorrow, I’ll discuss the pros and cons of taking NUA treatment.
Labels:
Investments,
Savings Buckets
Thursday, March 26, 2009
Special Tax Treatment for Employer Stock
The Beach Boys said it best. Rah, rah, rah, be true to your school. In that spirit, the Tax Code grants special tax benefits to investment of your employer retirement plan account in stock of your employer. These tax goodies were enacted before anyone ever heard of Enron.
A reader has asked an arcane question about qualifying for this special tax treatment. I’ll get to that tomorrow when I discuss how to qualify. For today, I will first focus on just what that tax treatment is.
Here’s the deal, in a nutshell. If you receive a distribution of employer stock from your employer’s tax-favored retirement plan, and that stock has appreciated in value since the plan bought it, you can pay tax on just a portion of the distribution—i.e., the amount the stock cost the trustee of the plan—and defer tax on the appreciation until you actually sell the stock. Upon that sale, the appreciation is taxed as long-term capital gain, often at a lower rate than ordinary income. (That balance is called Net Unrealized Appreciation, or NUA for short, and the special tax deal is sometimes called “NUA treatment” by the jargonistas.)
For the interested, here’s a summary of the whole picture:
• The amount currently subject to income tax is not the fair market value of the employer stock. Rather it is the original cost to the plan of the employer stock, which might be a fraction of its value, particularly if you have been a plan participant for many years, and much of the stock was purchased a long time ago. Unfortunately, just about everybody has experienced a bad case of NUA shrinkage over the last year or so.
• The plan trustee will report both the stock’s original cost and its fair market value to you on a Form 1099-R at the time of the distribution.
• Taxation of the difference between the current fair market value and the plan’s original cost—the stock’s NUA—is delayed until you sell the stock.
• Your tax basis in the employer stock is its fair market value, reduced by the NUA. In other words, your tax basis is the amount you paid tax on.
• When you sell the stock, you are entitled to treat the NUA as long-term capital gain regardless of how long you (or the employer retirement plan) have held the stock. Long-term capital gain is often taxed at a lower rate than ordinary income.
• Any additional appreciation between the date of distribution and the date of a later stock sale is treated as long- or short-term capital gain, depending on how long you have held the stock, measured from the date the retirement plan distributed it to you.
• If you are under age 59-1/2 at the time of the stock distribution, you will be subject to a 10% penalty tax on the stock’s original cost, unless an exception applies, as discussed in February 19’s post. You will not be subject to the 10% penalty tax on the NUA, even if you sell the stock before age 59-1/2.
• If the lump sum distribution includes cash as well as employer stock, you may roll over the cash in a tax-free rollover, and enjoy NUA treatment on the stock.
• Or you may roll over the employer stock to an IRA or other tax-favored retirement plan, foregoing NUA treatment in favor of continued tax deferral.
• You may also roll over part of the employer stock and take NUA treatment on the balance.
• If you die still holding the employer stock, the NUA is taxed to your heirs (as long-term capital gain) when they sell the stock. They do not get a new stepped up tax basis in that part of the stock’s appreciation, as they do with other appreciated assets.
• If you are entitled to NUA treatment, you don’t have to take it. You may waive it, typically by opting instead to roll over the stock to a traditional IRA, or by paying ordinary income tax on the distribution.
So that’s it in a nutshell. Tomorrow I will discuss the requirements for qualifying for this deal. And in a later post, I’ll discuss how to determine whether to take advantage of it. It’s often not as good a deal as it’s cracked up to be.
A reader has asked an arcane question about qualifying for this special tax treatment. I’ll get to that tomorrow when I discuss how to qualify. For today, I will first focus on just what that tax treatment is.
Here’s the deal, in a nutshell. If you receive a distribution of employer stock from your employer’s tax-favored retirement plan, and that stock has appreciated in value since the plan bought it, you can pay tax on just a portion of the distribution—i.e., the amount the stock cost the trustee of the plan—and defer tax on the appreciation until you actually sell the stock. Upon that sale, the appreciation is taxed as long-term capital gain, often at a lower rate than ordinary income. (That balance is called Net Unrealized Appreciation, or NUA for short, and the special tax deal is sometimes called “NUA treatment” by the jargonistas.)
For the interested, here’s a summary of the whole picture:
• The amount currently subject to income tax is not the fair market value of the employer stock. Rather it is the original cost to the plan of the employer stock, which might be a fraction of its value, particularly if you have been a plan participant for many years, and much of the stock was purchased a long time ago. Unfortunately, just about everybody has experienced a bad case of NUA shrinkage over the last year or so.
• The plan trustee will report both the stock’s original cost and its fair market value to you on a Form 1099-R at the time of the distribution.
• Taxation of the difference between the current fair market value and the plan’s original cost—the stock’s NUA—is delayed until you sell the stock.
• Your tax basis in the employer stock is its fair market value, reduced by the NUA. In other words, your tax basis is the amount you paid tax on.
• When you sell the stock, you are entitled to treat the NUA as long-term capital gain regardless of how long you (or the employer retirement plan) have held the stock. Long-term capital gain is often taxed at a lower rate than ordinary income.
• Any additional appreciation between the date of distribution and the date of a later stock sale is treated as long- or short-term capital gain, depending on how long you have held the stock, measured from the date the retirement plan distributed it to you.
• If you are under age 59-1/2 at the time of the stock distribution, you will be subject to a 10% penalty tax on the stock’s original cost, unless an exception applies, as discussed in February 19’s post. You will not be subject to the 10% penalty tax on the NUA, even if you sell the stock before age 59-1/2.
• If the lump sum distribution includes cash as well as employer stock, you may roll over the cash in a tax-free rollover, and enjoy NUA treatment on the stock.
• Or you may roll over the employer stock to an IRA or other tax-favored retirement plan, foregoing NUA treatment in favor of continued tax deferral.
• You may also roll over part of the employer stock and take NUA treatment on the balance.
• If you die still holding the employer stock, the NUA is taxed to your heirs (as long-term capital gain) when they sell the stock. They do not get a new stepped up tax basis in that part of the stock’s appreciation, as they do with other appreciated assets.
• If you are entitled to NUA treatment, you don’t have to take it. You may waive it, typically by opting instead to roll over the stock to a traditional IRA, or by paying ordinary income tax on the distribution.
So that’s it in a nutshell. Tomorrow I will discuss the requirements for qualifying for this deal. And in a later post, I’ll discuss how to determine whether to take advantage of it. It’s often not as good a deal as it’s cracked up to be.
Labels:
Investments,
Savings Buckets
Monday, March 23, 2009
Short-Term vs. Long-Term Tax Savings
Yesterday’s post discussed an issue that arises frequently in different guises. Yesterday, the specific question was whether the cost of delaying a Roth conversion from 2009 to 2010 outweighs the benefit of 2010’s special sale on Roth IRA conversions.
Now here is another similar question in a form that arises all the time, not just in 2010. Convinced of the long-term benefit of Roth-ification, you have decided to Roth-ificate a large pre-existing traditional IRA you’ve accumulated over many years. Fortunately, you have a stash of funds in a taxable investment account to pay the tax cost of doing so. If you do it all at once, some of your IRA will be Roth-ificated at your current marginal tax bracket of, say, 28%, but some will be layered onto the next tax bracket of 33%; and maybe some will cost even more, at 35%. Alternatively, you can spread out the process over a few years and keep the tax cost of the whole thing at 28%. Which is your better option?
It turns out, you have to know a lot about how you approach your retirement planning before you can even begin to answer the question. Consider this chain of reasoning:
• Obviously, an important factor is the rate at which you project your traditional IRA will grow.
• But wait! Another important factor is the rate at which you project your taxable investment account will grow, since this is the savings bucket which will be diminished each time you pay the tax cost of Roth-ification.
• But wait! Those two factors depend on your asset allocation. Obviously you are going to project a different growth rate for your fixed income investments than for your equity investments. So what’s your projected long-term asset allocation?
• But wait! You should be rebalancing your asset classes periodically—at least I hope you are—particularly after you have spent a big chunk of dollars out of your taxable account for the privilege of converting a piece of your traditional IRA to a Roth IRA. So do you intend to rebalance after each annual tax expenditure?
• But wait! Which asset classes are in each of your savings buckets? Maybe you wisely engage in asset location planning as described in February 13’s post, so that you prefer to house your equities in one type of savings bucket and your fixed income in a different savings bucket. So to answer the questions posed in the first two bullet points, you have to know your asset location plan. What’s your asset location plan?
• But wait! You can’t properly adopt an asset location plan until you know which savings bucket you plan to tap first after you retire. In February 12’s post I called that spigot planning. So what’s your spigot plan?
• But wait! How can you adopt a spigot plan without knowing how much you plan to spend each year; how do you plan to make those savings buckets last a lifetime? So you have to know your retirement spending plan. What’s your retirement spending plan?
• But wait! You can’t really adopt a retirement spending plan until you project how much you’ll have at retirement. For that, you need a retirement saving plan—how much you plan to save each year during your working years. What’s your retirement saving plan?
• But wait! Your annual retirement savings have to go somewhere. You’ll need to prioritize which savings buckets to add your annual savings to, as illustrated in March 2’s post. What’s your bucket destination plan?
It’s all a vast seamless web, isn’t it. It’s like you have to project the entire course of your life in order to make a seemingly simple tax decision. No wonder people are short-sighted. It’s so much easier.
Now here is another similar question in a form that arises all the time, not just in 2010. Convinced of the long-term benefit of Roth-ification, you have decided to Roth-ificate a large pre-existing traditional IRA you’ve accumulated over many years. Fortunately, you have a stash of funds in a taxable investment account to pay the tax cost of doing so. If you do it all at once, some of your IRA will be Roth-ificated at your current marginal tax bracket of, say, 28%, but some will be layered onto the next tax bracket of 33%; and maybe some will cost even more, at 35%. Alternatively, you can spread out the process over a few years and keep the tax cost of the whole thing at 28%. Which is your better option?
It turns out, you have to know a lot about how you approach your retirement planning before you can even begin to answer the question. Consider this chain of reasoning:
• Obviously, an important factor is the rate at which you project your traditional IRA will grow.
• But wait! Another important factor is the rate at which you project your taxable investment account will grow, since this is the savings bucket which will be diminished each time you pay the tax cost of Roth-ification.
• But wait! Those two factors depend on your asset allocation. Obviously you are going to project a different growth rate for your fixed income investments than for your equity investments. So what’s your projected long-term asset allocation?
• But wait! You should be rebalancing your asset classes periodically—at least I hope you are—particularly after you have spent a big chunk of dollars out of your taxable account for the privilege of converting a piece of your traditional IRA to a Roth IRA. So do you intend to rebalance after each annual tax expenditure?
• But wait! Which asset classes are in each of your savings buckets? Maybe you wisely engage in asset location planning as described in February 13’s post, so that you prefer to house your equities in one type of savings bucket and your fixed income in a different savings bucket. So to answer the questions posed in the first two bullet points, you have to know your asset location plan. What’s your asset location plan?
• But wait! You can’t properly adopt an asset location plan until you know which savings bucket you plan to tap first after you retire. In February 12’s post I called that spigot planning. So what’s your spigot plan?
• But wait! How can you adopt a spigot plan without knowing how much you plan to spend each year; how do you plan to make those savings buckets last a lifetime? So you have to know your retirement spending plan. What’s your retirement spending plan?
• But wait! You can’t really adopt a retirement spending plan until you project how much you’ll have at retirement. For that, you need a retirement saving plan—how much you plan to save each year during your working years. What’s your retirement saving plan?
• But wait! Your annual retirement savings have to go somewhere. You’ll need to prioritize which savings buckets to add your annual savings to, as illustrated in March 2’s post. What’s your bucket destination plan?
It’s all a vast seamless web, isn’t it. It’s like you have to project the entire course of your life in order to make a seemingly simple tax decision. No wonder people are short-sighted. It’s so much easier.
Labels:
Roth Savings,
Savings Buckets
Sunday, March 22, 2009
2009 vs. 2010 Roth IRA Conversion
Let me share with you a real-life issue presented by a reader: He has a traditional IRA which he would like to convert to a Roth IRA. His 2009 modified Adjusted Gross Income is under $100,000 so he can do it this year. Or he can do it in 2010, regardless of his AGI. Remember, if he does the Roth conversion in 2010, that’s the year of the IRS’s Great Roth Sales Event. You have the option of spreading the taxable income from a 2010 conversion over two years, 2011 and 2012, as described in February 28’s post. So which is the better option?
Here are the considerations we came up with:
• There’s always the possibility that Congress changes the law and eliminates or restricts Roth conversions beginning in 2010. So that factor favors the 2009 conversion. Grab it while you can.
• Some people harbor the fear that some time in the future a deficit-strapped Congress will renege and make Roth IRA distributions (or part of them) taxable. I personally don’t think that’s very likely. But, hey, you never know. But that gets to whether any Roth conversion is wise, not when to do it. So, that’s a push.
• What are your tax brackets in 2009, 2011, and 2011? A low tax bracket year is a factor favoring the Roth conversion in that year.
• If you expect to have high income in 2011 or 2012, you can’t ignore the possibility of a tax rate increase, as has been proposed. And if you are thinking about converting a large IRA, the conversion itself will make you a high-income person for that year.
• If you expect your IRA to grow with investment earnings, that growth favors doing the Roth conversion now. Waiting nine months until 2010 will increase the amount of income that’s taxed in order to get a given portion of your IRA converted.
• The IRS’s Great Roth Sales Event in 2010 favors waiting until 2010. You get the benefit of a bit of tax deferral. How much is that worth? I ballpark it as making a Great Roth Sales Event conversion about 7.5% cheaper than a regular 2009 conversion, assuming the same tax brackets in 2009 as 2011 and 2012. Here’s where I get that number: In 2010, the IRS lets you defer half the taxable income for one year, and half for two years. That’s an average of 1.5 years’ deferral. Add another year of tax payment deferral you get by waiting for 2009 to turn into 2010. If you invest the expected tax cost in a tax-exempt money market fund, you might project 3% per year return. So that works out to a 7.5% discount on the tax.
• How does that 7.5% discount compare to your projected growth in the IRA over the next nine months? If you’ve got your IRA invested in fixed income investments, that factor favors waiting until 2010, since your IRA is not likely to grow by that amount in nine months. On the other hand, if your IRA is invested in equities, it’s been hammered pretty hard over the last 17 months. Is it time for the turnaround we’re all dreaming about? Ask yourself, are you feeling lucky?
• Here’s an important bit of advice. Whenever you do the Roth conversion, whether it’s March 2009 or during the IRS’s 2010 Great Roth Sales Event, estimate your tax cost based on the market value of the converted IRA and invest that conservatively while you wait for tax payment day to roll around. Particularly if you’re taking advantage of the 2010 Sale. Payment may be delayed, but the tax will soon be due. You don’t want to get whipsawed by investing the IRS’s interest-free loan in equities, which then go down in value before tax bill date arrives.
• There might be another factor that comes into play. If you delay the conversion until 2010, how will you be investing the money that's outside your IRA for the next nine months? The arithmetic three bullet points ago assumed it’s invested in a tax-exempt money market. But what if you’ve got it invested in equities, or in the same mix of equities and fixed income as your IRA? (The caution urged in the last bullet point gets triggered by the Roth conversion, but doesn’t necessarily apply while you’re waiting nine months to convert.) That tends to increase the breakeven rate of growth at which the 2009 conversion beats the 2010 conversion.
So which is better, 2009 conversion or 2010 Great Roth Sales Event conversion? Bottom line, nobody knows. If you can think of a factor I’ve left out, please post a comment or send me an email. TheTwoLeggedStool@gmail.com.
Here are the considerations we came up with:
• There’s always the possibility that Congress changes the law and eliminates or restricts Roth conversions beginning in 2010. So that factor favors the 2009 conversion. Grab it while you can.
• Some people harbor the fear that some time in the future a deficit-strapped Congress will renege and make Roth IRA distributions (or part of them) taxable. I personally don’t think that’s very likely. But, hey, you never know. But that gets to whether any Roth conversion is wise, not when to do it. So, that’s a push.
• What are your tax brackets in 2009, 2011, and 2011? A low tax bracket year is a factor favoring the Roth conversion in that year.
• If you expect to have high income in 2011 or 2012, you can’t ignore the possibility of a tax rate increase, as has been proposed. And if you are thinking about converting a large IRA, the conversion itself will make you a high-income person for that year.
• If you expect your IRA to grow with investment earnings, that growth favors doing the Roth conversion now. Waiting nine months until 2010 will increase the amount of income that’s taxed in order to get a given portion of your IRA converted.
• The IRS’s Great Roth Sales Event in 2010 favors waiting until 2010. You get the benefit of a bit of tax deferral. How much is that worth? I ballpark it as making a Great Roth Sales Event conversion about 7.5% cheaper than a regular 2009 conversion, assuming the same tax brackets in 2009 as 2011 and 2012. Here’s where I get that number: In 2010, the IRS lets you defer half the taxable income for one year, and half for two years. That’s an average of 1.5 years’ deferral. Add another year of tax payment deferral you get by waiting for 2009 to turn into 2010. If you invest the expected tax cost in a tax-exempt money market fund, you might project 3% per year return. So that works out to a 7.5% discount on the tax.
• How does that 7.5% discount compare to your projected growth in the IRA over the next nine months? If you’ve got your IRA invested in fixed income investments, that factor favors waiting until 2010, since your IRA is not likely to grow by that amount in nine months. On the other hand, if your IRA is invested in equities, it’s been hammered pretty hard over the last 17 months. Is it time for the turnaround we’re all dreaming about? Ask yourself, are you feeling lucky?
• Here’s an important bit of advice. Whenever you do the Roth conversion, whether it’s March 2009 or during the IRS’s 2010 Great Roth Sales Event, estimate your tax cost based on the market value of the converted IRA and invest that conservatively while you wait for tax payment day to roll around. Particularly if you’re taking advantage of the 2010 Sale. Payment may be delayed, but the tax will soon be due. You don’t want to get whipsawed by investing the IRS’s interest-free loan in equities, which then go down in value before tax bill date arrives.
• There might be another factor that comes into play. If you delay the conversion until 2010, how will you be investing the money that's outside your IRA for the next nine months? The arithmetic three bullet points ago assumed it’s invested in a tax-exempt money market. But what if you’ve got it invested in equities, or in the same mix of equities and fixed income as your IRA? (The caution urged in the last bullet point gets triggered by the Roth conversion, but doesn’t necessarily apply while you’re waiting nine months to convert.) That tends to increase the breakeven rate of growth at which the 2009 conversion beats the 2010 conversion.
So which is better, 2009 conversion or 2010 Great Roth Sales Event conversion? Bottom line, nobody knows. If you can think of a factor I’ve left out, please post a comment or send me an email. TheTwoLeggedStool@gmail.com.
Labels:
Roth Savings,
Savings Buckets
Saturday, March 21, 2009
The Grandchild’s Inherited Retirement Account
Yesterday’s post discussed the likelihood of leaving your children an inheritance—in particular an inherited retirement account of some kind.
As long as inheritance is likely, you might consider skipping your children and leaving some or all of your unspent retirement account to your grandchildren, especially if your kids are doing well enough on their own.
There’s three reasons this might be a particularly good idea. First, your grandchildren may still be facing their high-cost years and can better use the money. You know: college education, their first house, the cost of raising their own kids. Second, being younger, they may not yet have reached their peak earning years, and might therefore be in a lower income tax bracket—a consideration in the case of a traditional IRA which throws off lots of taxable income. Third, their younger age means they are allowed a longer period over which to stretch out distributions.
Here’s an example. Let’s say the facts are almost the same as in yesterday’s post: Three brothers each with a $100,000 account—a taxable investment account, a traditional IRA and a Roth IRA. But their named beneficiaries, instead of being their children, are their granddaughters (Patty, Maxine, and Laverne) . And they are age 25, with a life expectancy-based distribution period of 58.2 years. Here is the inflation-adjusted annual after-tax distribution each of the girls projects:
Patty (taxable account): $3,821 per year
Maxine (traditional IRA): $3,727 per year
Laverne (Roth IRA): $5,325 per year
But if instead the girls take only required minimum distributions, and reinvest the proceeds, here is what they project they can accumulate over a 59-year distribution period:
Patty (taxable account): $3,827,572
Maxine (traditional IRA): $4,671,516
Laverne (Roth IRA): $6,673,594
Myth has it that Einstein thought compound interest to be one of the miracles of the universe. And that was before the advent of IRA’s.
As long as inheritance is likely, you might consider skipping your children and leaving some or all of your unspent retirement account to your grandchildren, especially if your kids are doing well enough on their own.
There’s three reasons this might be a particularly good idea. First, your grandchildren may still be facing their high-cost years and can better use the money. You know: college education, their first house, the cost of raising their own kids. Second, being younger, they may not yet have reached their peak earning years, and might therefore be in a lower income tax bracket—a consideration in the case of a traditional IRA which throws off lots of taxable income. Third, their younger age means they are allowed a longer period over which to stretch out distributions.
Here’s an example. Let’s say the facts are almost the same as in yesterday’s post: Three brothers each with a $100,000 account—a taxable investment account, a traditional IRA and a Roth IRA. But their named beneficiaries, instead of being their children, are their granddaughters (Patty, Maxine, and Laverne) . And they are age 25, with a life expectancy-based distribution period of 58.2 years. Here is the inflation-adjusted annual after-tax distribution each of the girls projects:
Patty (taxable account): $3,821 per year
Maxine (traditional IRA): $3,727 per year
Laverne (Roth IRA): $5,325 per year
But if instead the girls take only required minimum distributions, and reinvest the proceeds, here is what they project they can accumulate over a 59-year distribution period:
Patty (taxable account): $3,827,572
Maxine (traditional IRA): $4,671,516
Laverne (Roth IRA): $6,673,594
Myth has it that Einstein thought compound interest to be one of the miracles of the universe. And that was before the advent of IRA’s.
Labels:
Retirement Spending Plan,
Savings Buckets
Friday, March 20, 2009
The Unintentional Inherited Retirement Account
Chances are pretty good your kids are going to inherit a retirement account from you. “No way!” you say, “I’m spending that on me!” “Way!” I reply.
As previously pointed out in prior posts, your inability to predict the future—how long you will live, what your investments will earn, what financial emergencies will befall you—will lead you to avoid draining your savings buckets dry. Like it or not, inheritance is a by-product of uncertainty.
And if you engage in clever spigot planning in an effort to boost your own retirement spending—as I am sure you will—chances are pretty good the last bucket standing will be a tax-favored retirement account of some kind—either a traditional retirement account or a Roth retirement account, or perhaps some of both.
To put an even finer point on this prediction, chances are pretty good your retirement account (or accounts) will be IRA’s rather than 401(k) or other employer plan accounts. Why? Because somewhere along the way, after you have left employment, you will have rolled over your employer plan accounts into IRA’s, due to the greater control you can exercise over them compared to the potential restrictions of employer plans (as pointed out in February 18’s post).
So your kids are probably in for an inherited IRA despite your best efforts to die broke. What’s it worth to them?
Here’s a little thought experiment. Picture three different brothers, Huey, Dewey and Louie. Each dies with a $100,000 account left to his sole 45-year old daughter, Patty, Maxine and Laverne, respectively. The only difference is that Patty’s inheritance is in an ordinary taxable investment account; Maxine’s is in a traditional IRA, and Laverne’s is in a Roth IRA. These are all different animals, so they are worth something different to the girls. How can we compare their values? Here’s one way. Since the IRS assigns a 45-year old beneficiary a 39-year distribution period, as described in yesterday’s post, we can ask how much of an after-tax inflation-adjusted stream of payments might the different savings buckets be projected to provide the girls over a 39-year period. Using reasonable assumptions, here’s what the girls project:
Patty (taxable account): $4,582 per year
Maxine (traditional IRA): $4,154 per year
Laverne (Roth IRA): $5,934 per year
The results are not terribly surprising. Laverne’s Roth IRA gives her the largest payout (by a wide margin), since she benefits from both a tax-exempt savings bucket and tax-free distributions. Patty comes in second with her taxable investment account; she has to pay tax on her investment earnings, but not on any distributions from the bucket. And Maxine comes in third with her traditional IRA; she benefits from a tax-exempt savings bucket, but the tax she has to pay on distributions outweighs that benefit.
But now let’s look at it another way. What if the girls have other sources of spending, and instead choose to let the inherited money continue to be reinvested? In other words, they’re savers rather than spenders. Maxine and Laverne take IRA distributions only in the minimum amount required by law, and then reinvest the after-tax amount remaining in a taxable investment account. By the end of 39 years, the IRA’s will have been completely distributed into taxable investment accounts just like Patty’s. Then the amount of after-tax dollars the girls project they can accumulate over 39 years will be as follows:
Patty (taxable account): $1,151,334
Maxine (traditional IRA): $1,156,783
Laverne (Roth IRA): $1,652,547
In a surprise reversal, over 39 years Maxine’s $100,000 IRA turns into a taxable account worth (a bit) more than Patty’s $100,000 taxable account. The benefit of the traditional IRA’s tax-exemption, combined with the slow stretching out of distributions, ends up overcoming the detriment of having to pay income tax on the distributions. It’s a miracle!
Either way, your kids’ unintentional inheritance can give them a leg up on their own retirement planning. Rest in peace.
As previously pointed out in prior posts, your inability to predict the future—how long you will live, what your investments will earn, what financial emergencies will befall you—will lead you to avoid draining your savings buckets dry. Like it or not, inheritance is a by-product of uncertainty.
And if you engage in clever spigot planning in an effort to boost your own retirement spending—as I am sure you will—chances are pretty good the last bucket standing will be a tax-favored retirement account of some kind—either a traditional retirement account or a Roth retirement account, or perhaps some of both.
To put an even finer point on this prediction, chances are pretty good your retirement account (or accounts) will be IRA’s rather than 401(k) or other employer plan accounts. Why? Because somewhere along the way, after you have left employment, you will have rolled over your employer plan accounts into IRA’s, due to the greater control you can exercise over them compared to the potential restrictions of employer plans (as pointed out in February 18’s post).
So your kids are probably in for an inherited IRA despite your best efforts to die broke. What’s it worth to them?
Here’s a little thought experiment. Picture three different brothers, Huey, Dewey and Louie. Each dies with a $100,000 account left to his sole 45-year old daughter, Patty, Maxine and Laverne, respectively. The only difference is that Patty’s inheritance is in an ordinary taxable investment account; Maxine’s is in a traditional IRA, and Laverne’s is in a Roth IRA. These are all different animals, so they are worth something different to the girls. How can we compare their values? Here’s one way. Since the IRS assigns a 45-year old beneficiary a 39-year distribution period, as described in yesterday’s post, we can ask how much of an after-tax inflation-adjusted stream of payments might the different savings buckets be projected to provide the girls over a 39-year period. Using reasonable assumptions, here’s what the girls project:
Patty (taxable account): $4,582 per year
Maxine (traditional IRA): $4,154 per year
Laverne (Roth IRA): $5,934 per year
The results are not terribly surprising. Laverne’s Roth IRA gives her the largest payout (by a wide margin), since she benefits from both a tax-exempt savings bucket and tax-free distributions. Patty comes in second with her taxable investment account; she has to pay tax on her investment earnings, but not on any distributions from the bucket. And Maxine comes in third with her traditional IRA; she benefits from a tax-exempt savings bucket, but the tax she has to pay on distributions outweighs that benefit.
But now let’s look at it another way. What if the girls have other sources of spending, and instead choose to let the inherited money continue to be reinvested? In other words, they’re savers rather than spenders. Maxine and Laverne take IRA distributions only in the minimum amount required by law, and then reinvest the after-tax amount remaining in a taxable investment account. By the end of 39 years, the IRA’s will have been completely distributed into taxable investment accounts just like Patty’s. Then the amount of after-tax dollars the girls project they can accumulate over 39 years will be as follows:
Patty (taxable account): $1,151,334
Maxine (traditional IRA): $1,156,783
Laverne (Roth IRA): $1,652,547
In a surprise reversal, over 39 years Maxine’s $100,000 IRA turns into a taxable account worth (a bit) more than Patty’s $100,000 taxable account. The benefit of the traditional IRA’s tax-exemption, combined with the slow stretching out of distributions, ends up overcoming the detriment of having to pay income tax on the distributions. It’s a miracle!
Either way, your kids’ unintentional inheritance can give them a leg up on their own retirement planning. Rest in peace.
Labels:
Retirement Spending Plan,
Savings Buckets
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)